Comments on: Being More Open http://ycoolthing.com/archives/583/being-more-open One Cool Thing from Yahoo! every weekday Sat, 05 Jul 2008 17:10:33 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: jr http://ycoolthing.com/archives/583/being-more-open#comment-1223 jr Sat, 19 Jan 2008 01:25:03 +0000 http://ycoolthing.com/archives/583/being-more-open#comment-1223 [Removing Official matching Yahoo! Mantle and PopPom set] Yeah, I agree that it'd be WAY cooler if we were an OpenID consumer rather than just another publisher, but I'm trying my best to get folks moving on that end too. In truth, I don't think we'll ever really open things up to anyone using an OpenID like we do someone who's got a Y!ID (So, probably no email, chat or message boards) but there's lots of other stuff we can do. As for merging content, yes and no. One of the aspects of OpenID is that it's just that. That means that each instance of an OpenID is distinct. It's kind of up to the OpenID consumer to do the work of tying your AOL OpenID to your Yahoo! OpenID. Again, possible, but does require effort both on your part and the consuming sites part. [Redonning Official Y! Stuffage] [Removing Official matching Yahoo! Mantle and PopPom set]

Yeah, I agree that it’d be WAY cooler if we were an OpenID consumer rather than just another publisher, but I’m trying my best to get folks moving on that end too. In truth, I don’t think we’ll ever really open things up to anyone using an OpenID like we do someone who’s got a Y!ID (So, probably no email, chat or message boards) but there’s lots of other stuff we can do.

As for merging content, yes and no. One of the aspects of OpenID is that it’s just that. That means that each instance of an OpenID is distinct. It’s kind of up to the OpenID consumer to do the work of tying your AOL OpenID to your Yahoo! OpenID. Again, possible, but does require effort both on your part and the consuming sites part.

[Redonning Official Y! Stuffage]

]]> By: Sean http://ycoolthing.com/archives/583/being-more-open#comment-1222 Sean Thu, 17 Jan 2008 22:41:34 +0000 http://ycoolthing.com/archives/583/being-more-open#comment-1222 That is really cool, this will definitely make it much easier for Yahoo! users to use OpenID sites and it adds a boatload of potential automatic users to any sites that support OpenID. Awesome! But it is a sort of awkward position to be in as a site that provides credentials but doesn't use them ourselves. Obviously, we're still helping provide support for the OpenID movement and that's sweet, and this is a huge feature for existing Yahoo! users who trust Yahoo! and want to use that login on other sites, but it feels like we're not adding much for existing OpenID users. As you mentioned, of course, this is just a first step, and I guess it's hard to say whether, given how carefully we guard Yahoo! IDs to be secure and trusted, if we can start accepting credentials into Yahoo! systems for just anyone who can run an OpenID login server. But it will definitely be interesting times ahead to see where we go with this. :) I'm not as familiar with OpenID; would there be the facility to take an existing OpenID that you had already used to contribute to other sites out there and merge it with a Yahoo! OpenID? That is really cool, this will definitely make it much easier for Yahoo! users to use OpenID sites and it adds a boatload of potential automatic users to any sites that support OpenID. Awesome! But it is a sort of awkward position to be in as a site that provides credentials but doesn’t use them ourselves. Obviously, we’re still helping provide support for the OpenID movement and that’s sweet, and this is a huge feature for existing Yahoo! users who trust Yahoo! and want to use that login on other sites, but it feels like we’re not adding much for existing OpenID users.

As you mentioned, of course, this is just a first step, and I guess it’s hard to say whether, given how carefully we guard Yahoo! IDs to be secure and trusted, if we can start accepting credentials into Yahoo! systems for just anyone who can run an OpenID login server. But it will definitely be interesting times ahead to see where we go with this. :)

I’m not as familiar with OpenID; would there be the facility to take an existing OpenID that you had already used to contribute to other sites out there and merge it with a Yahoo! OpenID?

]]>